/export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/starexec_run_ttt2-1.17+nonreach /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.xml /export/starexec/sandbox2/output/output_files -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- YES Problem: app(app(*(),x),app(app(+(),y),z)) -> app(app(+(),app(app(*(),x),y)),app(app(*(),x),z)) app(app(map(),f),nil()) -> nil() app(app(map(),f),app(app(cons(),x),xs)) -> app(app(cons(),app(f,x)),app(app(map(),f),xs)) app(app(filter(),f),nil()) -> nil() app(app(filter(),f),app(app(cons(),x),xs)) -> app(app(app(app(filter2(),app(f,x)),f),x),xs) app(app(app(app(filter2(),true()),f),x),xs) -> app(app(cons(),x),app(app(filter(),f),xs)) app(app(app(app(filter2(),false()),f),x),xs) -> app(app(filter(),f),xs) Proof: Extended Uncurrying Processor: application symbol: app symbol table: false ==> false0/0 true ==> true0/0 filter2 ==> filter20/0 filter21/1 filter22/2 filter23/3 filter24/4 filter ==> filter0/0 filter1/1 filter2/2 cons ==> cons0/0 cons1/1 cons2/2 nil ==> nil0/0 map ==> map0/0 map1/1 map2/2 + ==> +0/0 +1/1 +2/2 * ==> *0/0 *1/1 *2/2 uncurry-rules: app(*1(x5),x6) -> *2(x5,x6) app(*0(),x5) -> *1(x5) app(+1(x8),x9) -> +2(x8,x9) app(+0(),x8) -> +1(x8) app(map1(x11),x12) -> map2(x11,x12) app(map0(),x11) -> map1(x11) app(cons1(x15),x16) -> cons2(x15,x16) app(cons0(),x15) -> cons1(x15) app(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter2(x18,x19) app(filter0(),x18) -> filter1(x18) app(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter24(x21,x22,x23,x24) app(filter22(x21,x22),x23) -> filter23(x21,x22,x23) app(filter21(x21),x22) -> filter22(x21,x22) app(filter20(),x21) -> filter21(x21) eta-rules: problem: *2(x,+2(y,z)) -> +2(*2(x,y),*2(x,z)) map2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() map2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> cons2(app(f,x),map2(f,xs)) filter2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() filter2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter24(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter24(true0(),f,x,xs) -> cons2(x,filter2(f,xs)) filter24(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter2(f,xs) app(*1(x5),x6) -> *2(x5,x6) app(*0(),x5) -> *1(x5) app(+1(x8),x9) -> +2(x8,x9) app(+0(),x8) -> +1(x8) app(map1(x11),x12) -> map2(x11,x12) app(map0(),x11) -> map1(x11) app(cons1(x15),x16) -> cons2(x15,x16) app(cons0(),x15) -> cons1(x15) app(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter2(x18,x19) app(filter0(),x18) -> filter1(x18) app(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter24(x21,x22,x23,x24) app(filter22(x21,x22),x23) -> filter23(x21,x22,x23) app(filter21(x21),x22) -> filter22(x21,x22) app(filter20(),x21) -> filter21(x21) DP Processor: DPs: *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,z) *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,y) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> map{2,#}(f,xs) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter2{4,#}(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter2{4,#}(true0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) filter2{4,#}(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) app#(*1(x5),x6) -> *{2,#}(x5,x6) app#(map1(x11),x12) -> map{2,#}(x11,x12) app#(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter{2,#}(x18,x19) app#(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter2{4,#}(x21,x22,x23,x24) TRS: *2(x,+2(y,z)) -> +2(*2(x,y),*2(x,z)) map2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() map2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> cons2(app(f,x),map2(f,xs)) filter2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() filter2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter24(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter24(true0(),f,x,xs) -> cons2(x,filter2(f,xs)) filter24(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter2(f,xs) app(*1(x5),x6) -> *2(x5,x6) app(*0(),x5) -> *1(x5) app(+1(x8),x9) -> +2(x8,x9) app(+0(),x8) -> +1(x8) app(map1(x11),x12) -> map2(x11,x12) app(map0(),x11) -> map1(x11) app(cons1(x15),x16) -> cons2(x15,x16) app(cons0(),x15) -> cons1(x15) app(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter2(x18,x19) app(filter0(),x18) -> filter1(x18) app(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter24(x21,x22,x23,x24) app(filter22(x21,x22),x23) -> filter23(x21,x22,x23) app(filter21(x21),x22) -> filter22(x21,x22) app(filter20(),x21) -> filter21(x21) TDG Processor: DPs: *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,z) *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,y) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> map{2,#}(f,xs) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter2{4,#}(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter2{4,#}(true0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) filter2{4,#}(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) app#(*1(x5),x6) -> *{2,#}(x5,x6) app#(map1(x11),x12) -> map{2,#}(x11,x12) app#(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter{2,#}(x18,x19) app#(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter2{4,#}(x21,x22,x23,x24) TRS: *2(x,+2(y,z)) -> +2(*2(x,y),*2(x,z)) map2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() map2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> cons2(app(f,x),map2(f,xs)) filter2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() filter2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter24(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter24(true0(),f,x,xs) -> cons2(x,filter2(f,xs)) filter24(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter2(f,xs) app(*1(x5),x6) -> *2(x5,x6) app(*0(),x5) -> *1(x5) app(+1(x8),x9) -> +2(x8,x9) app(+0(),x8) -> +1(x8) app(map1(x11),x12) -> map2(x11,x12) app(map0(),x11) -> map1(x11) app(cons1(x15),x16) -> cons2(x15,x16) app(cons0(),x15) -> cons1(x15) app(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter2(x18,x19) app(filter0(),x18) -> filter1(x18) app(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter24(x21,x22,x23,x24) app(filter22(x21,x22),x23) -> filter23(x21,x22,x23) app(filter21(x21),x22) -> filter22(x21,x22) app(filter20(),x21) -> filter21(x21) graph: filter2{4,#}(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter2{4,#}(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter2{4,#}(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) filter2{4,#}(true0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter2{4,#}(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter2{4,#}(true0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter2{4,#}(app(f,x),f,x,xs) -> filter2{4,#}(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter2{4,#}(app(f,x),f,x,xs) -> filter2{4,#}(true0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) -> app#(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter2{4,#}(x21,x22,x23,x24) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) -> app#(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter{2,#}(x18,x19) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) -> app#(map1(x11),x12) -> map{2,#}(x11,x12) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) -> app#(*1(x5),x6) -> *{2,#}(x5,x6) app#(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter2{4,#}(x21,x22,x23,x24) -> filter2{4,#}(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) app#(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter2{4,#}(x21,x22,x23,x24) -> filter2{4,#}(true0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) app#(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter{2,#}(x18,x19) -> filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter2{4,#}(app(f,x),f,x,xs) app#(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter{2,#}(x18,x19) -> filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) app#(map1(x11),x12) -> map{2,#}(x11,x12) -> map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) app#(map1(x11),x12) -> map{2,#}(x11,x12) -> map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> map{2,#}(f,xs) app#(*1(x5),x6) -> *{2,#}(x5,x6) -> *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,y) app#(*1(x5),x6) -> *{2,#}(x5,x6) -> *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,z) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) -> app#(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter2{4,#}(x21,x22,x23,x24) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) -> app#(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter{2,#}(x18,x19) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) -> app#(map1(x11),x12) -> map{2,#}(x11,x12) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) -> app#(*1(x5),x6) -> *{2,#}(x5,x6) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> map{2,#}(f,xs) -> map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> map{2,#}(f,xs) -> map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> map{2,#}(f,xs) *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,z) -> *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,y) *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,z) -> *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,z) *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,y) -> *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,y) *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,y) -> *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,z) SCC Processor: #sccs: 2 #rules: 11 #arcs: 28/144 DPs: filter2{4,#}(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) app#(map1(x11),x12) -> map{2,#}(x11,x12) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> map{2,#}(f,xs) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) app#(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter{2,#}(x18,x19) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter2{4,#}(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter2{4,#}(true0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) app#(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter2{4,#}(x21,x22,x23,x24) TRS: *2(x,+2(y,z)) -> +2(*2(x,y),*2(x,z)) map2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() map2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> cons2(app(f,x),map2(f,xs)) filter2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() filter2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter24(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter24(true0(),f,x,xs) -> cons2(x,filter2(f,xs)) filter24(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter2(f,xs) app(*1(x5),x6) -> *2(x5,x6) app(*0(),x5) -> *1(x5) app(+1(x8),x9) -> +2(x8,x9) app(+0(),x8) -> +1(x8) app(map1(x11),x12) -> map2(x11,x12) app(map0(),x11) -> map1(x11) app(cons1(x15),x16) -> cons2(x15,x16) app(cons0(),x15) -> cons1(x15) app(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter2(x18,x19) app(filter0(),x18) -> filter1(x18) app(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter24(x21,x22,x23,x24) app(filter22(x21,x22),x23) -> filter23(x21,x22,x23) app(filter21(x21),x22) -> filter22(x21,x22) app(filter20(),x21) -> filter21(x21) Subterm Criterion Processor: simple projection: pi(map{2,#}) = 0 pi(app#) = 0 pi(filter{2,#}) = 0 pi(filter2{4,#}) = 1 problem: DPs: filter2{4,#}(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> map{2,#}(f,xs) map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> app#(f,x) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter2{4,#}(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter2{4,#}(true0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) TRS: *2(x,+2(y,z)) -> +2(*2(x,y),*2(x,z)) map2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() map2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> cons2(app(f,x),map2(f,xs)) filter2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() filter2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter24(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter24(true0(),f,x,xs) -> cons2(x,filter2(f,xs)) filter24(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter2(f,xs) app(*1(x5),x6) -> *2(x5,x6) app(*0(),x5) -> *1(x5) app(+1(x8),x9) -> +2(x8,x9) app(+0(),x8) -> +1(x8) app(map1(x11),x12) -> map2(x11,x12) app(map0(),x11) -> map1(x11) app(cons1(x15),x16) -> cons2(x15,x16) app(cons0(),x15) -> cons1(x15) app(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter2(x18,x19) app(filter0(),x18) -> filter1(x18) app(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter24(x21,x22,x23,x24) app(filter22(x21,x22),x23) -> filter23(x21,x22,x23) app(filter21(x21),x22) -> filter22(x21,x22) app(filter20(),x21) -> filter21(x21) SCC Processor: #sccs: 2 #rules: 4 #arcs: 20/36 DPs: map{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> map{2,#}(f,xs) TRS: *2(x,+2(y,z)) -> +2(*2(x,y),*2(x,z)) map2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() map2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> cons2(app(f,x),map2(f,xs)) filter2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() filter2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter24(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter24(true0(),f,x,xs) -> cons2(x,filter2(f,xs)) filter24(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter2(f,xs) app(*1(x5),x6) -> *2(x5,x6) app(*0(),x5) -> *1(x5) app(+1(x8),x9) -> +2(x8,x9) app(+0(),x8) -> +1(x8) app(map1(x11),x12) -> map2(x11,x12) app(map0(),x11) -> map1(x11) app(cons1(x15),x16) -> cons2(x15,x16) app(cons0(),x15) -> cons1(x15) app(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter2(x18,x19) app(filter0(),x18) -> filter1(x18) app(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter24(x21,x22,x23,x24) app(filter22(x21,x22),x23) -> filter23(x21,x22,x23) app(filter21(x21),x22) -> filter22(x21,x22) app(filter20(),x21) -> filter21(x21) Subterm Criterion Processor: simple projection: pi(map{2,#}) = 1 problem: DPs: TRS: *2(x,+2(y,z)) -> +2(*2(x,y),*2(x,z)) map2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() map2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> cons2(app(f,x),map2(f,xs)) filter2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() filter2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter24(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter24(true0(),f,x,xs) -> cons2(x,filter2(f,xs)) filter24(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter2(f,xs) app(*1(x5),x6) -> *2(x5,x6) app(*0(),x5) -> *1(x5) app(+1(x8),x9) -> +2(x8,x9) app(+0(),x8) -> +1(x8) app(map1(x11),x12) -> map2(x11,x12) app(map0(),x11) -> map1(x11) app(cons1(x15),x16) -> cons2(x15,x16) app(cons0(),x15) -> cons1(x15) app(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter2(x18,x19) app(filter0(),x18) -> filter1(x18) app(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter24(x21,x22,x23,x24) app(filter22(x21,x22),x23) -> filter23(x21,x22,x23) app(filter21(x21),x22) -> filter22(x21,x22) app(filter20(),x21) -> filter21(x21) Qed DPs: filter2{4,#}(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) filter{2,#}(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter2{4,#}(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter2{4,#}(true0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) TRS: *2(x,+2(y,z)) -> +2(*2(x,y),*2(x,z)) map2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() map2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> cons2(app(f,x),map2(f,xs)) filter2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() filter2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter24(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter24(true0(),f,x,xs) -> cons2(x,filter2(f,xs)) filter24(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter2(f,xs) app(*1(x5),x6) -> *2(x5,x6) app(*0(),x5) -> *1(x5) app(+1(x8),x9) -> +2(x8,x9) app(+0(),x8) -> +1(x8) app(map1(x11),x12) -> map2(x11,x12) app(map0(),x11) -> map1(x11) app(cons1(x15),x16) -> cons2(x15,x16) app(cons0(),x15) -> cons1(x15) app(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter2(x18,x19) app(filter0(),x18) -> filter1(x18) app(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter24(x21,x22,x23,x24) app(filter22(x21,x22),x23) -> filter23(x21,x22,x23) app(filter21(x21),x22) -> filter22(x21,x22) app(filter20(),x21) -> filter21(x21) Subterm Criterion Processor: simple projection: pi(filter{2,#}) = 1 pi(filter2{4,#}) = 3 problem: DPs: filter2{4,#}(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) filter2{4,#}(true0(),f,x,xs) -> filter{2,#}(f,xs) TRS: *2(x,+2(y,z)) -> +2(*2(x,y),*2(x,z)) map2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() map2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> cons2(app(f,x),map2(f,xs)) filter2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() filter2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter24(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter24(true0(),f,x,xs) -> cons2(x,filter2(f,xs)) filter24(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter2(f,xs) app(*1(x5),x6) -> *2(x5,x6) app(*0(),x5) -> *1(x5) app(+1(x8),x9) -> +2(x8,x9) app(+0(),x8) -> +1(x8) app(map1(x11),x12) -> map2(x11,x12) app(map0(),x11) -> map1(x11) app(cons1(x15),x16) -> cons2(x15,x16) app(cons0(),x15) -> cons1(x15) app(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter2(x18,x19) app(filter0(),x18) -> filter1(x18) app(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter24(x21,x22,x23,x24) app(filter22(x21,x22),x23) -> filter23(x21,x22,x23) app(filter21(x21),x22) -> filter22(x21,x22) app(filter20(),x21) -> filter21(x21) SCC Processor: #sccs: 0 #rules: 0 #arcs: 4/4 DPs: *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,z) *{2,#}(x,+2(y,z)) -> *{2,#}(x,y) TRS: *2(x,+2(y,z)) -> +2(*2(x,y),*2(x,z)) map2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() map2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> cons2(app(f,x),map2(f,xs)) filter2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() filter2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter24(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter24(true0(),f,x,xs) -> cons2(x,filter2(f,xs)) filter24(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter2(f,xs) app(*1(x5),x6) -> *2(x5,x6) app(*0(),x5) -> *1(x5) app(+1(x8),x9) -> +2(x8,x9) app(+0(),x8) -> +1(x8) app(map1(x11),x12) -> map2(x11,x12) app(map0(),x11) -> map1(x11) app(cons1(x15),x16) -> cons2(x15,x16) app(cons0(),x15) -> cons1(x15) app(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter2(x18,x19) app(filter0(),x18) -> filter1(x18) app(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter24(x21,x22,x23,x24) app(filter22(x21,x22),x23) -> filter23(x21,x22,x23) app(filter21(x21),x22) -> filter22(x21,x22) app(filter20(),x21) -> filter21(x21) Subterm Criterion Processor: simple projection: pi(*{2,#}) = 1 problem: DPs: TRS: *2(x,+2(y,z)) -> +2(*2(x,y),*2(x,z)) map2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() map2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> cons2(app(f,x),map2(f,xs)) filter2(f,nil0()) -> nil0() filter2(f,cons2(x,xs)) -> filter24(app(f,x),f,x,xs) filter24(true0(),f,x,xs) -> cons2(x,filter2(f,xs)) filter24(false0(),f,x,xs) -> filter2(f,xs) app(*1(x5),x6) -> *2(x5,x6) app(*0(),x5) -> *1(x5) app(+1(x8),x9) -> +2(x8,x9) app(+0(),x8) -> +1(x8) app(map1(x11),x12) -> map2(x11,x12) app(map0(),x11) -> map1(x11) app(cons1(x15),x16) -> cons2(x15,x16) app(cons0(),x15) -> cons1(x15) app(filter1(x18),x19) -> filter2(x18,x19) app(filter0(),x18) -> filter1(x18) app(filter23(x21,x22,x23),x24) -> filter24(x21,x22,x23,x24) app(filter22(x21,x22),x23) -> filter23(x21,x22,x23) app(filter21(x21),x22) -> filter22(x21,x22) app(filter20(),x21) -> filter21(x21) Qed