NO Solver Timeout: 4 Global Timeout: 60 No parsing errors! Init Location: 0 Transitions: 0) /\ (arg2 > ~(1)), par{arg1 -> 0}> 1, arg2 -> 2}> 1) /\ (1 = arg1), par{arg1 -> 1, arg2 -> (arg2 + 1)}> 1) /\ (0 = arg1), par{arg1 -> 0, arg2 -> (arg2 - 1)}> 10) /\ (1 = arg1), par{arg1 -> 1, arg2 -> (arg2 + 1)}> 10) /\ (0 = arg1), par{arg1 -> 0, arg2 -> (arg2 - 1)}> 0, arg2 -> 9}> undef15, arg2 -> undef16}> Fresh variables: undef15, undef16, Undef variables: undef15, undef16, Abstraction variables: Exit nodes: Accepting locations: Asserts: Preprocessed LLVMGraph Init Location: 0 Transitions: 0) /\ (undef16 > ~(1))> 1, arg2 -> 2}> 1) /\ (1 = arg1), par{arg1 -> 1, arg2 -> (arg2 + 1)}> 1) /\ (0 = arg1), par{arg1 -> 0, arg2 -> (arg2 - 1)}> 10) /\ (1 = arg1), par{arg1 -> 1, arg2 -> (arg2 + 1)}> 10) /\ (0 = arg1), par{arg1 -> 0, arg2 -> (arg2 - 1)}> 0, arg2 -> 9}> Fresh variables: undef15, undef16, Undef variables: undef15, undef16, Abstraction variables: Exit nodes: Accepting locations: Asserts: ************************************************************* ******************************************************************************************* *********************** WORKING TRANSITION SYSTEM (DAG) *********************** ******************************************************************************************* Init Location: 0 Graph 0: Transitions: Variables: Graph 1: Transitions: 1, arg2 -> 2, rest remain the same}> 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> 0, arg2 -> 9, rest remain the same}> Variables: arg2, arg1 Precedence: Graph 0 Graph 1 Map Locations to Subgraph: ( 0 , 0 ) ( 2 , 1 ) ******************************************************************************************* ******************************** CHECKING ASSERTIONS ******************************** ******************************************************************************************* Proving termination of subgraph 0 Proving termination of subgraph 1 Checking unfeasibility... Time used: 0.414939 Checking conditional termination of SCC {l2}... LOG: CALL solveLinear LOG: RETURN solveLinear - Elapsed time: 0.004948s LOG: CALL solveLinear LOG: RETURN solveLinear - Elapsed time: 0.074490s Trying to remove transition: 0, arg2 -> 9, rest remain the same}> Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 4.009882s Time used: 4.00858 Trying to remove transition: 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 0.588261s Time used: 0.583693 Trying to remove transition: 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 0.389367s Time used: 0.382389 Trying to remove transition: 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 4.008958s Time used: 4.00155 Trying to remove transition: 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 4.012928s Time used: 4.00717 Trying to remove transition: 1, arg2 -> 2, rest remain the same}> Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 3.166489s Time used: 3.16131 Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 0.121879s Time used: 0.103096 Improving Solution with cost 1 ... LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetNextSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetNextSolution - Elapsed time: 0.669380s Time used: 0.66933 LOG: SAT solveNonLinear - Elapsed time: 0.791259s Cost: 1; Total time: 0.772426 Failed at location 2: arg2 <= 0 Before Improving: Quasi-invariant at l2: arg2 <= 0 Optimizing invariants... LOG: CALL solveLinear LOG: RETURN solveLinear - Elapsed time: 0.009921s Remaining time after improvement: 0.99538 Termination implied by a set of quasi-invariant(s): Quasi-invariant at l2: arg2 <= 0 [ Invariant Graph ] Strengthening and disabling transitions... LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility It's unfeasible. Removing transition: 1, arg2 -> 2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility It's unfeasible. Removing transition: 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility It's unfeasible. Removing transition: 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility It's unfeasible. Removing transition: 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility It's unfeasible. Removing transition: 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility It's unfeasible. Removing transition: 0, arg2 -> 9, rest remain the same}> [ Termination Graph ] Strengthening and disabling transitions... LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility It's unfeasible. Removing transition: 1, arg2 -> 2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility It's unfeasible. Removing transition: 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility It's unfeasible. Removing transition: 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility It's unfeasible. Removing transition: 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility It's unfeasible. Removing transition: 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility It's unfeasible. Removing transition: 0, arg2 -> 9, rest remain the same}> New Graphs: Calling Safety with literal arg2 <= 0 and entry LOG: CALL check - Post:arg2 <= 0 - Process 1 * Exit transition: * Postcondition : arg2 <= 0 LOG: CALL solveLinear LOG: RETURN solveLinear - Elapsed time: 0.001014s > Postcondition is not implied! LOG: RETURN check - Elapsed time: 0.001117s INVARIANTS: 2: Quasi-INVARIANTS to narrow Graph: 2: arg2 <= 0 , Narrowing transition: 1, arg2 -> 2, rest remain the same}> LOG: Narrow transition size 1 Narrowing transition: 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: Narrow transition size 1 Narrowing transition: 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: Narrow transition size 1 Narrowing transition: 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: Narrow transition size 1 Narrowing transition: 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: Narrow transition size 1 Narrowing transition: 0, arg2 -> 9, rest remain the same}> LOG: Narrow transition size 1 invGraph after Narrowing: Transitions: 1, arg2 -> 2, rest remain the same}> 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> 0, arg2 -> 9, rest remain the same}> Variables: arg2, arg1 Checking conditional termination of SCC {l2}... LOG: CALL solveLinear LOG: RETURN solveLinear - Elapsed time: 0.002214s LOG: CALL solveLinear LOG: RETURN solveLinear - Elapsed time: 0.076253s Trying to remove transition: 0, arg2 -> 9, rest remain the same}> Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 4.004144s Time used: 4.00271 Trying to remove transition: 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 0.605839s Time used: 0.599264 Trying to remove transition: 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 0.406094s Time used: 0.397908 Trying to remove transition: 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 4.011133s Time used: 4.00288 Trying to remove transition: 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 3.336304s Time used: 3.32971 Trying to remove transition: 1, arg2 -> 2, rest remain the same}> Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 1.034003s Time used: 0.988095 Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 0.967532s Time used: 0.955496 Solving with 2 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 0.974001s Time used: 0.962414 Solving with 3 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 1.004519s Time used: 0.978978 Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 0.999425s Time used: 0.992765 Proving non-termination of subgraph 1 Transitions: 1, arg2 -> 2, rest remain the same}> 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> 0, arg2 -> 9, rest remain the same}> Variables: arg2, arg1 Checking conditional non-termination of SCC {l2}... EXIT TRANSITIONS: Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 0.038183s Time used: 0.037859 Improving Solution with cost 7 ... LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetNextSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetNextSolution - Elapsed time: 1.021339s Time used: 1.01682 LOG: SAT solveNonLinear - Elapsed time: 1.059522s Cost: 7; Total time: 1.05468 Non-termination implied by a set of quasi-invariant(s): Quasi-invariant at l2: arg1 <= 1 Strengthening and disabling EXIT transitions... Closed exits from l2: 3 Strengthening exit transition (result): Strengthening exit transition (result): Strengthening exit transition (result): Strengthening exit transition (result): Strengthening and disabling transitions... LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 1, arg2 -> 2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 0, arg2 -> 9, rest remain the same}> Checking conditional non-termination of SCC {l2}... EXIT TRANSITIONS: Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 0.033857s Time used: 0.033529 Improving Solution with cost 4 ... LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetNextSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetNextSolution - Elapsed time: 1.001371s Time used: 1.0013 LOG: SAT solveNonLinear - Elapsed time: 1.035228s Cost: 4; Total time: 1.03483 Non-termination implied by a set of quasi-invariant(s): Quasi-invariant at l2: 0 <= arg1 Strengthening and disabling EXIT transitions... Closed exits from l2: 2 Strengthening exit transition (result): Strengthening exit transition (result): Strengthening and disabling transitions... LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 1, arg2 -> 2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 0, arg2 -> 9, rest remain the same}> Checking conditional non-termination of SCC {l2}... EXIT TRANSITIONS: Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 0.025564s Time used: 0.02525 Improving Solution with cost 1 ... LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetNextSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetNextSolution - Elapsed time: 0.040608s Time used: 0.0406 LOG: SAT solveNonLinear - Elapsed time: 0.066172s Cost: 1; Total time: 0.06585 Non-termination implied by a set of quasi-invariant(s): Quasi-invariant at l2: arg1 <= arg2 Strengthening and disabling EXIT transitions... Closed exits from l2: 1 Strengthening exit transition (result): Strengthening and disabling transitions... LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 1, arg2 -> 2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 0, arg2 -> 9, rest remain the same}> Checking conditional non-termination of SCC {l2}... EXIT TRANSITIONS: Solving with 1 template(s). LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetFirstSolution - Elapsed time: 0.019572s Time used: 0.019238 Improving Solution with cost 1 ... LOG: CALL solveNonLinearGetNextSolution LOG: RETURN solveNonLinearGetNextSolution - Elapsed time: 0.038730s Time used: 0.037681 LOG: SAT solveNonLinear - Elapsed time: 0.058302s Cost: 1; Total time: 0.056919 Failed at location 2: 1 <= arg2 Before Improving: Quasi-invariant at l2: 1 <= arg2 Optimizing invariants... LOG: CALL solveLinear LOG: RETURN solveLinear - Elapsed time: 0.015130s Remaining time after improvement: 0.997274 Non-termination implied by a set of quasi-invariant(s): Quasi-invariant at l2: 1 <= arg2 Strengthening and disabling EXIT transitions... Closed exits from l2: 1 Strengthening and disabling transitions... LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 1, arg2 -> 2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 1, arg2 -> 1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 0, arg2 -> -1 + arg2, rest remain the same}> LOG: CALL solverLinear in Graph for feasibility LOG: RETURN solveLinear in Graph for feasibility Strengthening transition (result): 0, arg2 -> 9, rest remain the same}> Calling reachability with... Transition: Conditions: arg1 <= 1, 0 <= arg1, arg1 <= arg2, 1 <= arg2, OPEN EXITS: --- Reachability graph --- > Graph without transitions. Calling reachability with... Transition: Conditions: arg1 <= arg2, 0 <= arg1, 1 <= arg2, arg1 <= 1, OPEN EXITS: > Conditions are reachable! Program does NOT terminate