YES Problem 1: (VAR v_NonEmpty:S x1:S) (RULES a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ) Problem 1: Dependency Pairs Processor: -> Pairs: A(a(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) A(a(x1:S)) -> D(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(c(x1:S))) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) D(d(x1:S)) -> A(c(x1:S)) D(d(x1:S)) -> B(a(c(x1:S))) D(d(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) Problem 1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: A(a(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) A(a(x1:S)) -> D(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(c(x1:S))) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) D(d(x1:S)) -> A(c(x1:S)) D(d(x1:S)) -> B(a(c(x1:S))) D(d(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Strongly Connected Components: ->->Cycle: ->->-> Pairs: A(a(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) A(a(x1:S)) -> D(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(c(x1:S))) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) D(d(x1:S)) -> A(c(x1:S)) D(d(x1:S)) -> B(a(c(x1:S))) D(d(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) ->->-> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) Problem 1: Reduction Pair Processor: -> Pairs: A(a(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) A(a(x1:S)) -> D(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(c(x1:S))) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) D(d(x1:S)) -> A(c(x1:S)) D(d(x1:S)) -> B(a(c(x1:S))) D(d(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) -> Usable rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Interpretation type: Linear ->Coefficients: All rationals ->Dimension: 1 ->Bound: 4 ->Interpretation: [a](X) = X + 1 [b](X) = X + 1 [c](X) = X + 1/2 [d](X) = X + 3/2 [A](X) = 1/4.X + 3/4 [B](X) = 1/4.X + 3/4 [C](X) = 1/4.X + 3/4 [D](X) = 1/4.X + 3/4 Problem 1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: A(a(x1:S)) -> D(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(c(x1:S))) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) D(d(x1:S)) -> A(c(x1:S)) D(d(x1:S)) -> B(a(c(x1:S))) D(d(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Strongly Connected Components: ->->Cycle: ->->-> Pairs: A(a(x1:S)) -> D(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(c(x1:S))) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) D(d(x1:S)) -> A(c(x1:S)) D(d(x1:S)) -> B(a(c(x1:S))) D(d(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) ->->-> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) Problem 1: Reduction Pair Processor: -> Pairs: A(a(x1:S)) -> D(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(c(x1:S))) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) D(d(x1:S)) -> A(c(x1:S)) D(d(x1:S)) -> B(a(c(x1:S))) D(d(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) -> Usable rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Interpretation type: Linear ->Coefficients: All rationals ->Dimension: 1 ->Bound: 4 ->Interpretation: [a](X) = X + 2/3 [b](X) = X + 2/3 [c](X) = X + 1/3 [d](X) = X + 1 [A](X) = 2.X + 4/3 [B](X) = 2.X + 4/3 [C](X) = 2.X + 2/3 [D](X) = 2.X + 4/3 Problem 1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(c(x1:S))) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) D(d(x1:S)) -> A(c(x1:S)) D(d(x1:S)) -> B(a(c(x1:S))) D(d(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Strongly Connected Components: ->->Cycle: ->->-> Pairs: A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(c(x1:S))) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) ->->-> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) Problem 1: Reduction Pair Processor: -> Pairs: A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(c(x1:S))) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) -> Usable rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Interpretation type: Linear ->Coefficients: All rationals ->Dimension: 1 ->Bound: 4 ->Interpretation: [a](X) = X + 4/3 [b](X) = X + 4/3 [c](X) = X + 2/3 [d](X) = X + 2 [A](X) = 2.X + 1/4 [B](X) = 2.X + 1/3 [C](X) = 2.X Problem 1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Strongly Connected Components: ->->Cycle: ->->-> Pairs: A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) ->->-> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) Problem 1: Reduction Pair Processor: -> Pairs: A(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) -> Usable rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Interpretation type: Linear ->Coefficients: All rationals ->Dimension: 1 ->Bound: 4 ->Interpretation: [a](X) = X + 2 [b](X) = X + 2 [c](X) = X + 1 [d](X) = X + 3 [A](X) = 2.X [B](X) = 2.X + 1/2 [C](X) = 2.X + 2/3 Problem 1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Strongly Connected Components: ->->Cycle: ->->-> Pairs: A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) ->->-> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) Problem 1: Reduction Pair Processor: -> Pairs: A(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) -> Usable rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Interpretation type: Linear ->Coefficients: All rationals ->Dimension: 1 ->Bound: 4 ->Interpretation: [a](X) = X + 2 [b](X) = X + 2 [c](X) = X + 1 [d](X) = X + 3 [A](X) = 1/4.X + 2 [B](X) = 1/4.X + 2 [C](X) = 1/4.X + 2 Problem 1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: B(b(x1:S)) -> A(c(c(x1:S))) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(a(x1:S)) C(d(x1:S)) -> A(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Strongly Connected Components: ->->Cycle: ->->-> Pairs: B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) ->->-> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) Problem 1: Reduction Pair Processor: -> Pairs: B(b(x1:S)) -> C(c(x1:S)) B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) -> Usable rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Interpretation type: Linear ->Coefficients: All rationals ->Dimension: 1 ->Bound: 4 ->Interpretation: [a](X) = X + 4/3 [b](X) = X + 4/3 [c](X) = X + 2/3 [d](X) = X + 2 [B](X) = 2.X + 1/4 [C](X) = 2.X + 2/3 Problem 1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Strongly Connected Components: ->->Cycle: ->->-> Pairs: B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) ->->-> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) Problem 1: Subterm Processor: -> Pairs: B(b(x1:S)) -> C(x1:S) C(c(x1:S)) -> B(x1:S) -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Projection: pi(B) = 1 pi(C) = 1 Problem 1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: Empty -> Rules: a(a(x1:S)) -> d(c(x1:S)) a(b(x1:S)) -> c(c(c(x1:S))) b(b(x1:S)) -> a(c(c(x1:S))) c(c(x1:S)) -> b(x1:S) c(d(x1:S)) -> a(a(x1:S)) d(d(x1:S)) -> b(a(c(x1:S))) ->Strongly Connected Components: There is no strongly connected component The problem is finite.