YES Problem 1: (VAR v_NonEmpty:S X:S X1:S X2:S Y:S Z:S) (RULES a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) ) (STRATEGY INNERMOST) Problem 1: Dependency Pairs Processor: -> Pairs: A__FIRST(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> MARK(Y:S) A__FROM(X:S) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> A__FIRST(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X2:S) MARK(from(X:S)) -> A__FROM(mark(X:S)) MARK(from(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(s(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) -> Rules: a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) Problem 1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: A__FIRST(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> MARK(Y:S) A__FROM(X:S) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> A__FIRST(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X2:S) MARK(from(X:S)) -> A__FROM(mark(X:S)) MARK(from(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(s(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) -> Rules: a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) ->Strongly Connected Components: ->->Cycle: ->->-> Pairs: A__FIRST(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> MARK(Y:S) A__FROM(X:S) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> A__FIRST(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X2:S) MARK(from(X:S)) -> A__FROM(mark(X:S)) MARK(from(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(s(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) ->->-> Rules: a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) Problem 1: Reduction Pairs Processor: -> Pairs: A__FIRST(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> MARK(Y:S) A__FROM(X:S) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> A__FIRST(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X2:S) MARK(from(X:S)) -> A__FROM(mark(X:S)) MARK(from(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(s(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) -> Rules: a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) -> Usable rules: a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) ->Interpretation type: Linear ->Coefficients: Natural Numbers ->Dimension: 1 ->Bound: 2 ->Interpretation: [a__first](X1,X2) = 2.X1 + 2.X2 + 2 [a__from](X) = 2.X + 2 [mark](X) = 2.X [0] = 2 [cons](X1,X2) = X1 + 2 [fSNonEmpty] = 0 [first](X1,X2) = 2.X1 + 2.X2 + 1 [from](X) = 2.X + 2 [nil] = 0 [s](X) = X + 2 [A__FIRST](X1,X2) = 2.X1 + 2.X2 + 2 [A__FROM](X) = 2.X + 2 [MARK](X) = 2.X + 2 Problem 1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: A__FROM(X:S) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> A__FIRST(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X2:S) MARK(from(X:S)) -> A__FROM(mark(X:S)) MARK(from(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(s(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) -> Rules: a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) ->Strongly Connected Components: ->->Cycle: ->->-> Pairs: A__FROM(X:S) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X2:S) MARK(from(X:S)) -> A__FROM(mark(X:S)) MARK(from(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(s(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) ->->-> Rules: a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) Problem 1: Reduction Pairs Processor: -> Pairs: A__FROM(X:S) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X2:S) MARK(from(X:S)) -> A__FROM(mark(X:S)) MARK(from(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(s(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) -> Rules: a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) -> Usable rules: a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) ->Interpretation type: Linear ->Coefficients: Natural Numbers ->Dimension: 1 ->Bound: 2 ->Interpretation: [a__first](X1,X2) = X1 + 2.X2 + 2 [a__from](X) = 2.X + 2 [mark](X) = 2.X + 1 [0] = 2 [cons](X1,X2) = X1 [fSNonEmpty] = 0 [first](X1,X2) = X1 + 2.X2 + 2 [from](X) = 2.X + 2 [nil] = 2 [s](X) = X [A__FIRST](X1,X2) = 0 [A__FROM](X) = 2.X + 2 [MARK](X) = 2.X + 1 Problem 1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: MARK(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X2:S) MARK(from(X:S)) -> A__FROM(mark(X:S)) MARK(from(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(s(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) -> Rules: a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) ->Strongly Connected Components: ->->Cycle: ->->-> Pairs: MARK(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X2:S) MARK(from(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(s(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) ->->-> Rules: a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) Problem 1: Subterm Processor: -> Pairs: MARK(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X1:S) MARK(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> MARK(X2:S) MARK(from(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) MARK(s(X:S)) -> MARK(X:S) -> Rules: a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) ->Projection: pi(MARK) = 1 Problem 1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: Empty -> Rules: a__first(0,X:S) -> nil a__first(s(X:S),cons(Y:S,Z:S)) -> cons(mark(Y:S),first(X:S,Z:S)) a__first(X1:S,X2:S) -> first(X1:S,X2:S) a__from(X:S) -> cons(mark(X:S),from(s(X:S))) a__from(X:S) -> from(X:S) mark(0) -> 0 mark(cons(X1:S,X2:S)) -> cons(mark(X1:S),X2:S) mark(first(X1:S,X2:S)) -> a__first(mark(X1:S),mark(X2:S)) mark(from(X:S)) -> a__from(mark(X:S)) mark(nil) -> nil mark(s(X:S)) -> s(mark(X:S)) ->Strongly Connected Components: There is no strongly connected component The problem is finite.