/export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/starexec_run_tc20-rel.sh /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.xml /export/starexec/sandbox2/output/output_files -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- YES ************************************************** summary ************************************************** SRS with 3 strict rules and 3 weak rules on 3 letters tile all, by Config { method = Overlap,width = 2,unlabel = True} SRS with 48 strict rules and 48 weak rules on 15 letters weights SRS with 37 strict rules and 44 weak rules on 15 letters remove some, by Config { method = Overlap,width = 2,unlabel = True} SRS with 33 strict rules and 40 weak rules on 14 letters weights SRS with 30 strict rules and 40 weak rules on 13 letters Matrix { monotone = Strict, domain = Natural, shape = Full, bits = 3, dim = 2, solver = Minisatapi, verbose = False, tracing = False} SRS with 23 rules on 10 letters weights SRS with 0 rules on 0 letters no strict rules ************************************************** proof ************************************************** property Termination has value Just True for SRS [a, b, b] -> [c, b, a] {- Input 0 -} [a, a, c] -> [b, c, a] {- Input 1 -} [a, a, b] -> [a, c, b] {- Input 2 -} [b, a, a] ->= [c, a, a] {- Input 3 -} [c, b, b] ->= [b, a, a] {- Input 4 -} [c, b, a] ->= [b, c, c] {- Input 5 -} reason Tiling { method = Overlap, width = 2, state_type = Bit64, map_type = Enum, unlabel = True, print_completion_steps = False, print_tiles = False, verbose = False, tracing = True} steps 1 using 15 tiles tile all rules steps: 1 property Termination has value Just True for SRS [[<, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, >]] -> [ [<, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 0 (Input 0)) -} [[<, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, a]] -> [ [<, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 0)) -} [[<, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, b]] -> [ [<, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 0)) -} [[<, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [<, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, >]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, a]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, b]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[b, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, >]] -> [ [b, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 0)) -} [[b, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, a]] -> [ [b, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 0)) -} [[b, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, b]] -> [ [b, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 0)) -} [[b, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [b, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, >]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, a]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, b]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[<, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, >]] -> [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 0 (Input 1)) -} [[<, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[<, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[<, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, >]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, >]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, >]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[<, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [<, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[<, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [<, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[<, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [<, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[<, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [<, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, >]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 0 (Input 4)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, >]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 4)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, >]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 4)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, >]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 4)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , > ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 0 (Input 5)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} reason ([<, a], 8/1) ([b, >], 8/1) property Termination has value Just True for SRS [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, a]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, b]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[b, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, a]] -> [ [b, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 0)) -} [[b, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, b]] -> [ [b, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 0)) -} [[b, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [b, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, a]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, b]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, >]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, >]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, >]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[<, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [<, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[<, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [<, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[<, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [<, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[<, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [<, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , > ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 0 (Input 5)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} reason Tiling { method = Overlap, width = 2, state_type = Bit64, map_type = Enum, unlabel = True, print_completion_steps = False, print_tiles = False, verbose = False, tracing = True} steps 1 using 65 tiles remove some unmatched rules steps: 1 property Termination has value Just True for SRS [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, a]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, b]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[b, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, a]] -> [ [b, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 0)) -} [[b, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, b]] -> [ [b, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 0)) -} [[b, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [b, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, a]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, b]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, >]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, >]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, >]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} reason ([c, >], 3/1) property Termination has value Just True for SRS [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, a]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, b]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[b, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, a]] -> [ [b, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 0)) -} [[b, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, b]] -> [ [b, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 0)) -} [[b, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [b, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, a]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, b]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[<, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [<, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[a, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [a, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[b, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [b, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, >]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 3)) -} [[c, b], [b, a], [a, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [c, c] , [c, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 3)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, a]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 4)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, b]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 4)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, b], [b, c]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, a] , [a, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 4)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[<, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [<, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 0 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[a, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[b, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, a]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, b]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 5)) -} [[c, c], [c, b], [b, a], [a, c]] ->= [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, c] , [ c , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 5)) -} reason ( [a, a] , St / 2 0 \ \ 0 1 / ) ( [a, b] , St / 2 0 \ \ 0 1 / ) ( [b, b] , St / 2 1 \ \ 0 1 / ) ( [b, a] , St / 2 1 \ \ 0 1 / ) ( [a, c] , St / 2 0 \ \ 0 1 / ) ( [c, b] , St / 2 0 \ \ 0 1 / ) ( [b, c] , St / 2 0 \ \ 0 1 / ) ( [c, a] , St / 2 0 \ \ 0 1 / ) ( [c, c] , St / 2 0 \ \ 0 1 / ) ( [a, >] , St / 2 1 \ \ 0 1 / ) ( [b, >] , St / 1 1 \ \ 0 1 / ) ( [<, b] , St / 1 0 \ \ 0 1 / ) ( [<, c] , St / 1 0 \ \ 0 1 / ) property Termination has value Just True for SRS [[a, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [a, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[c, a], [a, b], [b, b], [b, c]] -> [ [c, c] , [c, b] , [b, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 0)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [a, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [b, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, a]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, b]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 1)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, c], [c, c]] -> [ [c, b] , [b, c] , [c, a] , [ a , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 1)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[a, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [a, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 1 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[b, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [b, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 2 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, >]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , > ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 0 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, a]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , a ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 1 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, b]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , b ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 2 (Input 2)) -} [[c, a], [a, a], [a, b], [b, c]] -> [ [c, a] , [a, c] , [c, b] , [ b , c ] ] {- Semlab 3 (Concon 3 (Input 2)) -} reason ([a, a], 6/1) ([a, b], 3/2) ([b, a], 1/1) ([a, c], 1/1) ([c, a], 3/1) property Termination has value Just True for SRS reason no strict rules ************************************************** skeleton: (3/3,3)\TileAllROC{2}(48/48,15)\Weight(37/44,15)\TileRemoveROC{2}(33/40,14)\Weight(30/40,13)\Matrix{\Natural}{2}(23,10)\Weight(0,0)[] ************************************************** let {} in let {done = Worker No_Strict_Rules;mo = Pre (Or_Else Count (IfSizeLeq 100000 GLPK Fail));wop = Or_Else (Worker (Weight {modus = mo})) Pass;weighted = \ m -> And_Then m wop;when_small = \ m -> And_Then (Worker (SizeAtmost 100)) m;when_medium = \ m -> And_Then (Worker (SizeAtmost 10000)) m;tiling = \ m w -> weighted (And_Then (Worker (Tiling {method = m,width = w,tracing = True})) (Worker Remap));matrix = \ mo dom dim bits -> when_small (weighted (Worker (Matrix {monotone = mo,domain = dom,dim = dim,bits = bits,shape = Corner})));kbo = \ b -> when_medium (weighted (Worker (KBO {bits = b,solver = Minisatapi})));yeah = Apply wop (Tree_Search_Preemptive 0 done ([ ] <> ([ kbo 1, And_Then (Worker Mirror) (kbo 1)] <> ((for [ 3, 4] (\ d -> matrix Strict Natural d 3)) <> (for [ 2, 3, 5] (\ w -> tiling Overlap w))))));noh = [ Timeout 5 (Worker (Enumerate {closure = Forward})), Timeout 5 (Worker (Enumerate {closure = Backward}))]} in Apply (Worker Remap) (First_Of ([ yeah] <> noh))