/export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/starexec_run_default /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.xml /export/starexec/sandbox2/output/output_files -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- YES Problem 1: (VAR v_NonEmpty:S l:S x:S y:S) (RULES le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue ) Problem 1: Valid CTRS Processor: -> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue -> The system is a deterministic 3-CTRS. Problem 1: Dependency Pairs Processor: Conditional Termination Problem 1: -> Pairs: LE(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> LE(x:S,y:S) MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S -> QPairs: Empty -> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue Conditional Termination Problem 2: -> Pairs: MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> LE(x:S,min(l:S)) MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) -> QPairs: LE(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> LE(x:S,y:S) MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S -> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue The problem is decomposed in 2 subproblems. Problem 1.1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: LE(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> LE(x:S,y:S) MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S -> QPairs: Empty -> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue ->Strongly Connected Components: ->->Cycle: ->->-> Pairs: MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S -> QPairs: Empty ->->-> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue ->->Cycle: ->->-> Pairs: LE(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> LE(x:S,y:S) -> QPairs: Empty ->->-> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue The problem is decomposed in 2 subproblems. Problem 1.1.1: Conditional Subterm Processor: -> Pairs: MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S -> QPairs: Empty -> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue ->Projection: pi(MIN) = 1 Problem 1.1.1: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: Empty -> QPairs: Empty -> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue ->Strongly Connected Components: There is no strongly connected component The problem is finite. Problem 1.1.2: Conditional Subterm Processor: -> Pairs: LE(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> LE(x:S,y:S) -> QPairs: Empty -> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue ->Projection: pi(LE) = 1 Problem 1.1.2: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: Empty -> QPairs: Empty -> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue ->Strongly Connected Components: There is no strongly connected component The problem is finite. Problem 1.2: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> LE(x:S,min(l:S)) MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) -> QPairs: LE(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> LE(x:S,y:S) MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S -> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue ->Strongly Connected Components: ->->Cycle: ->->-> Pairs: MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) -> QPairs: MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S ->->-> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue Problem 1.2: Conditional Subterm Processor: -> Pairs: MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) -> QPairs: MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse MIN(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> MIN(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S -> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue ->Projection: pi(MIN) = 1 Problem 1.2: SCC Processor: -> Pairs: Empty -> QPairs: Empty -> Rules: le(0,s(x:S)) -> ttrue le(s(x:S),s(y:S)) -> le(x:S,y:S) le(x:S,0) -> ffalse min(cons(x:S,nil)) -> x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ffalse min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> min(l:S) | min(l:S) ->* x:S min(cons(x:S,l:S)) -> x:S | le(x:S,min(l:S)) ->* ttrue ->Strongly Connected Components: There is no strongly connected component The problem is finite.